top of page

I Suppose That She'd Be Quiet Too!

Updated: Aug 3, 2023

My previous post on the Quiet Woman in Rainow had started a bit of an online conversation. It progressed something like this.

"Wasn't there another pub called the Quiet Woman?"

"There was one in Earl Sterndale which closed a couple of years ago."

"There's also one in Leek, but that too is currently closed, I believe. Possibly permanently."

"There was also was one on the A54 Chester to Nantwich Road."

"Isn't the A54 Chester to Buxton?"

"I meant the A51, and the pub was the Headless Woman. Sorry for the confusion."

It also sparked my interest, and a bit of census crawling and directory delving followed.

The Headless Woman was a pub on the A51, midway between Tarvin and Tarporley, in the village of Duddon.

It used to have a headless woman in its car park.

But what's with the name? Why the Headless Woman? The reason for that lies deep in the past.

Going back in time we can see, if we screw our eyes up tightly and try very hard, that the pub used to be a Chester Northgate house before that brewery was acquired by Greenhall Whitley in 1949...

Headless Woman Duddon
The Headless Woman whilst still a Chester Northgate house.

...but the history of the Headless Woman goes back a lot further than that. If we go back to 1834 we can see that it's listed in Pigot's directory with Alexander Maxwell as its innkeeper, even though the village's name has been misspelt, so the reason behind the name must go further back still.

Headless Woman Duddon
Extract from Pigot's 1834 directory.

The tale reputedly goes back to the time of the English Civil War. In 1644 parliamentarian troops found servant Grace Trigg hiding in the cellar of nearby Hockenhull Hall after her royalist masters had done a runner. They tortured her in an attempt to get her to reveal where the family's valuables were hidden and, when they failed to get any joy, they beheaded her in the attic of the pub and dumped her body into the River Gowy from one of the mediaeval packhorse bridges. Her ghost has been seen walking the locality ever since, her severed head neatly tucked under her arm. Washington Irving, of Rip Van Winkle fame, is reported to have stayed in the inn during his time in England with the story inspiring him to write The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.

The pub stood for a further three-hundred and seventy years after Grace lost her head, before its own fate was sealed. It closed, and was put up for sale, in the summer of 2011...

Headless Woman Duddon
The Headless Woman for sale in July 2011. © Google 2023

...and if we take a peek from the opposite direction it will be plain to see why it was such an attractive proposition for developers.

Headless Woman Duddon
The Headless Woman, and its extensive car park, in July 2011. © Google 2023

The pub was demolished in 2014 and new housing now occupies the site. Like so many lost pubs, such as Gorleston's White Horse and the Black Diamond in Blyth, its name lives on, carried by the adjacent bus stop.

Headless Woman Duddon
The site of the former Headless Woman, and its eponymous bus stop , in July 2022. © Google 2023

Just to round off I'd like to return to the conversation at the top of this piece. The Quiet Woman? Well, take a look at this entry in Pigot's 1828/9 edition.

Headless Woman Duddon
Extract from Pigot's 1828/9 directory.

Alexander Maxwell was obviously in residence at least half a dozen years before we met him above, and Pigot had managed to spell the village's name correctly this time, but look at the pub's name. I'm sure it wasn't really the Quick Woman. She was dead, after all, and the quick and the dead are two mutually exclusive groups. It's highly likely to have been a mistake and ought to have been the Quiet Woman. So Simon, you probably were correct with the name, but just a mere couple of hundred years out.

Eirian Evans' images are copyright and are reused under this licence. The map extract is reproduced with the permission of the National Library of Scotland and is used under this one.

If you've read this far, then thank you. Possibly, like me, you may have some sort of interest in bygone boozers. Clicking here will take you to a searchable/sortable index which you can use to see if I've already featured any lost locals from your locality. You can also subscribe to ensure that you don't miss any future posts. Simply click here to return to the home page (opens in a new tab), follow the 'Subscribe' link and complete the form to receive an email notification of any future post. Or you could simply follow the link at the top of this page.

760 views1 comment

Recent Posts

See All

1 Comment

Actually stopped here back in 2009 I think, used to pass often traveling from Anglesey to Nottingham so gave it a go. Was a decent little place, only annoyance was they served chips in a plant pot!

Really sad to see it gone for good, like so many along that route.

The davenport arms was another, and one who's name escapes me was nearer Snugburys on the right there. All now housing :(

bottom of page